Trust and honesty... opinions wanted

Major conversation with partner last night. Not really intentional. I'm curious y'all's take on this scenario (note this is not the scenario of us or anyone we know...but it's a real situation and led to a big conversation about the nature of trust and lying).

Situation. This girl is dating a guy long distance. He comes to visit and gets stuck with her during quarantine. His trip is obviously extended indefinitely. They have been dating about 6 months - she says he's her bf but doesn't say whether they have had the "exclusivity talk." He has mentioned a female friend to her that he doesn't talk to anymore...she gets the sense it was more than what he's saying. She looks at his phone and see evidence that it was at least an emotional affair situation (the other woman is married but her bf was single at the time) if not a physical relationship too. She sees that they last spoke a few weeks before she got together with the guy. She approaches him about it and he deleted everything off the phone except for one photo (which she finds later) where the guy admitted his love for this woman. She approaches him again and he admits it was more than just a friendship.

Questions that came up when my partner and I discussed. I'm curious your take:

  • was the guy wrong to not give the full truth on the relationship when she asked? Is that lying?

  • can this guy be trusted in the future?

  • how "should" this situation have played out?

  • does someone witholding info or telling half truths about one aspect of their life indicate they can't be trusted in other aspects?

My partner and I (for what it's worth I'm female and he's male, we are both in our 30s, have been together about 3 years, and live together) had very different opinions about this. he felt like she violated trust by snooping through his phone... And he said that the guy probably just wanted to leave the whole situation behind hence why he didn't give the full story. But I said that it's one thing if he didn't volunteer the information... But since she asked he should have been honest. The snooping isn't great obviously but considering she found out that he professes love for this woman only a few weeks before they got together it seems somewhat important.

My partner didn't seem to think there was any reason not to trust this person in the future. But I felt like if you couldn't be honest about this, there was a strong possibility he would lie again in the future especially if it benefited him to do so.

The way we both agreed the situation should have played out is that she should not have snooped, but, when asked he should have said that either he "didn't want to talk about the situation" or he could have said it was "complicated"...or he could have been honest. But telling her a half truth led to more suspicion and breach of trust.

What do you think? I feel like this issue has underlying implications for my relationship as well... How we regard trust and honesty. So would love some different opinions.

Tldr; partner and I discussed a situation about trust and honesty and it led to an interesting discussion... But are we really as in sync as I hoped we were?



Submitted March 31, 2020 at 12:08AM

Major conversation with partner last night. Not really intentional. I'm curious y'all's take on this scenario (note this is not the scenario of us or anyone we know...but it's a real situation and led to a big conversation about the nature of trust and lying).Situation. This girl is dating a guy long distance. He comes to visit and gets stuck with her during quarantine. His trip is obviously extended indefinitely. They have been dating about 6 months - she says he's her bf but doesn't say whether they have had the "exclusivity talk." He has mentioned a female friend to her that he doesn't talk to anymore...she gets the sense it was more than what he's saying. She looks at his phone and see evidence that it was at least an emotional affair situation (the other woman is married but her bf was single at the time) if not a physical relationship too. She sees that they last spoke a few weeks before she got together with the guy. She approaches him about it and he deleted everything off the phone except for one photo (which she finds later) where the guy admitted his love for this woman. She approaches him again and he admits it was more than just a friendship.Questions that came up when my partner and I discussed. I'm curious your take:was the guy wrong to not give the full truth on the relationship when she asked? Is that lying?can this guy be trusted in the future?how "should" this situation have played out?does someone witholding info or telling half truths about one aspect of their life indicate they can't be trusted in other aspects?My partner and I (for what it's worth I'm female and he's male, we are both in our 30s, have been together about 3 years, and live together) had very different opinions about this. he felt like she violated trust by snooping through his phone... And he said that the guy probably just wanted to leave the whole situation behind hence why he didn't give the full story. But I said that it's one thing if he didn't volunteer the information... But since she asked he should have been honest. The snooping isn't great obviously but considering she found out that he professes love for this woman only a few weeks before they got together it seems somewhat important.My partner didn't seem to think there was any reason not to trust this person in the future. But I felt like if you couldn't be honest about this, there was a strong possibility he would lie again in the future especially if it benefited him to do so.The way we both agreed the situation should have played out is that she should not have snooped, but, when asked he should have said that either he "didn't want to talk about the situation" or he could have said it was "complicated"...or he could have been honest. But telling her a half truth led to more suspicion and breach of trust.What do you think? I feel like this issue has underlying implications for my relationship as well... How we regard trust and honesty. So would love some different opinions.Tldr; partner and I discussed a situation about trust and honesty and it led to an interesting discussion... But are we really as in sync as I hoped we were?
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Add Comments, Posts, Links... etc.

Popular posts from this blog

The difference between being right and being understood

My boyfriend and I are 28. We’ve been together for about 1.5 years and recently moved in together. He’s a pretty patient and easygoing person (Type B) whereas I’m more particular (Type A). Of course there are two sides to every trait, and my Type A nature benefits us in some ways too. Like all couples, we have differences in perspective or preference. When this happens, he will usually say something like “I disagree (with your perspective) but fine.” I tend to push the issue in an attempt to get him to understand where I’m coming from. This escalates the disagreement into a fight because he perceives it as me trying to be “right”. I truly just want to be understood (and I want to understand where he’s coming from) so I’m looking for more of a dialogue whereas he avoids conflict and just wants it to be over as quickly as possible. His general approach is “agree to disagree” but that doesn’t make sense to me when it’s an issue that will keep coming up and requires compromise. I’m n...
Read more

My (27f) gf (27f) is getting tired of me not sharing intimate/ personal info about me

I’ve always been extremely private and introverted. We have more than a year together and we’ve been living together for like 6 months, we get along pretty good and I’m really in love with her, however I can not seem to open up... and I can tell it’s frustrating to her by the way she tells me it bothers her that she feels she’s the only one committed and the one that’s always sharing... At this point I don’t even know if it is that I’ve gotten too used to it, to the point I’ve became lazy to talk about myself or give any genuine personal opinion... it sucks, really, I need to communicate better... Where do I start? Tl;dr: I can’t be completely intimate with my gf and its frustrating her, I need to communicate better because I really love her... where to start? Submitted April 25, 2019 at 06:02AM I’ve always been extremely private and introverted. We have more than a year together and we’ve been living together for like 6 months, we get along pretty good and I’m really in love ...
Read more

My (23M) girlfriend (25F) relationship is confusing to me. I might be the problem, or maybe we are just incompatible.

I met my girlfriend after a few serious breakups that led me to change both intentionally and unintentionally over a few years. For better and for worse. She had just gotten out of an engagement with a verbally and physically abusive man who had a cocaine problem. We have been together about 8 months now. We hit it off and spent a lot of time together but she began to push our relationship as if there were a time clock for milestones. I was pressed beyond my comfort zone and went with it because of my affection for her. My living situation fell apart and I lost a few thousand dollars to shit roommates right around the time she and I met and she offered to let me stay with her. I agreed with some resistance. I pay for food, help her with bills, and throw money toward rent while trying to get back on my feet. As long as we have been together she has gotten more possessive, angry, and irrational. She is dealing with shit from her engagement and I feel shes looking for a level of seriou...
Read more